According to Keir Starmer’s ex-chief aide, the government is being hindered by the peculiarities of Whitehall. Paul Ovenden, former director of strategy at No10, suggested that the influence of a “Stakeholder State” has shifted power away from voters, leaving ministers feeling powerless. He criticized the excessive sway given to NGOs, activist lawyers, and celebrity-driven campaigns within the political landscape.
Ovenden highlighted the case of activist Alaa Abd El-Fattah, whose controversial social media posts were uncovered following the Prime Minister’s endorsement of his release from imprisonment in Egypt. Ovenden described the situation as a source of amusement in No10 due to its frequent mention, illustrating the diversion of time and attention towards peripheral issues.
He urged the government to demonstrate resolve and purpose in dismantling the system swiftly to address the change demanded by voters.
Ovenden, a long-time aide to Starmer, resigned last year following the leak of sexually explicit messages about veteran MP Diane Abbott in 2017. Despite this, he maintains close ties with influential figures in No10.
In his article for the Times, Ovenden remarked, “Fattah’s sudden emergence into the public eye has exposed the bizarre priorities of Whitehall.”
Ovenden criticized the Stakeholder State for its ambiguous political stance, accusing it of accommodating all viewpoints at any time and no viewpoint at all. He singled out the Tories for their contradictory actions, such as advocating for the deportation of Mr. El-Fattah while previously supporting him.
He argued that this issue extends beyond the immediate situation and is impeding the government’s ability to implement crucial changes, like infrastructure development and housing projects.
Describing the Stakeholder State as favoring consultations over action, Ovenden emphasized the gradual shift of power from voters to select groups with resources and access, resulting in their undue influence.
He concluded by stating, “A government with determination and purpose can swiftly dismantle much of the Stakeholder State, regaining its confidence and delivering the desired change.”
At Reach and across our entities , we and our partners utilize data gathered through cookies and other identifiers on your device to enhance site experience, analyze usage, and provide personalized ads. You can opt out of data sharing at any time by clicking the “Do Not Sell or Share my Data” button. Your preferences are specific to each browser. Your use of our services indicates acceptance of cookies and consent to our Privacy Notice and Terms and Conditions.